Used Toyota Highlander Hybrid for sale
7 below-market Toyota Highlander Hybrid listings, $21,218–$48,348, averaging 89,650 miles. Model years 2017–2025.
By model year
Toyota Highlander Hybrid listings
300KMile rating
300KMile rating
300KMile rating
300KMile rating
300KMile rating
300KMile rating
300KMile ratingWhat should you pay for a used Toyota Highlander Hybrid?
Across the 7 below-market Toyota Highlander Hybrid listings we track right now, the median asking price is $29,700 against a median market value of $30,919 — an average of 4.9% under. Typical mileage works out to about 15,500 miles a year, so a 2020 example carrying much more than 93,000 miles is above average for its age and should be priced accordingly.
These are dealer asking prices on cars already filtered to below-market listings, not sale prices, and they exclude tax, title and fees. Use them as a negotiating floor, not a valuation.
| Year | Median asking | Median market value | Avg. under market | Median miles | Listings |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 2025 | $48,348 | $49,688 | 2.7% | 23,543 | 1 |
| 2021 | $29,700 | $30,919 | 4.5% | 96,119 | 3 |
| 2020 | $36,691 | $38,597 | 4.9% | 67,573 | 1 |
| 2019 | $26,543 | $28,244 | 6% | 91,546 | 1 |
| 2017 | $21,218 | $22,904 | 7.4% | 128,567 | 1 |
Known Toyota Highlander Hybrid problems, by model year
2019, 2020 — Low-pressure fuel pump
Known issues to check on the Toyota Highlander Hybrid
One widely reported problem pattern applies to this model year. That does not mean this car has the fault — many were fixed under warranty or recall — but it is what to check, and what to ask the seller for, before you buy.
- Low-pressure fuel pumpWorth checking
A very large recall covers a Denso low-pressure fuel pump that can fail and stall the engine while driving.
What to check: Run the VIN through the manufacturer's recall lookup and confirm the fuel pump recall has been completed. It is a free fix, but it has to have been done.
Patterns are drawn from NHTSA recalls and complaints, manufacturer service bulletins and consistent owner reporting. Always confirm open recalls against the VIN and get an independent pre-purchase inspection.
Research the Toyota Highlander Hybrid
- Read owner reviewsWhat owners of this exact model year say about reliability, repairs and what they paid.Edmunds →
- Get roadside coverageRoadside assistance, towing and member discounts from day one.AAA →
- Lower your insuranceOnline course — many insurers give a discount for it.DefensiveDriving →
- Check your creditSee your credit score before you talk financing.Experian →
Partner links — Caboose may earn a commission if you buy through them, at no cost to you. It never affects which cars we list.